Extras (The Jam) – Compilation Album

by Emilio Pérez Miguel on November 27, 2009

"Extras" Assembles Rare Songs & Takes From All Over The Jam's Relatively Brief Career.

"Extras" Assembles Rare Songs & Takes From All Over The Jam's Relatively Brief Career.

Extras was a compilation of Jam b-sides, rare tracks and demos that was issued in 1992. The main value the compilation has always had is in portraying the development of Paul Weller as a composer, since cover versions that map out the way he shaped the sound of the trio as they went along are extensively provided. We have covers of The Beatles (“And You Bird Can Sing”), The Small Faces (the charged “Get Yourself Together”) and The Who (“Disguises” and “So Sad About Us”, the b-side to “Down In The Tube Station At Midnight” that paid tribute to the passing of Keith Moon) along with many R & B and soul covers like “Move On Up”, “I Got You (I Feel Good)” and “Fever” (which is fused with Paul’s own “Pity Poor Alfie”).

Some of the best original b-sides include “The Butterfly Collector” (a timeless take on the groupies and hangers on that have always littered the music scene), and the electric version of Foxton’s Smithers-Jones (a string quartet performs it on “Setting Sons“; the original version was the flipside to “When You Are Young”). There is also Weller’s own “Shopping” (a shuffly number that manages to marry the vision which led to the Style Council with the sound of The Jam) and the salient “Tales From The Riverbank”. That one has always been deemed as one of those “should have been an a-side” track by fans, critics and Weller himself. Its placement on the album is also very good, being situated right at the beginning with “The Dreams Of Children”.

There are also two unreleased Weller originals. They are “No One In The World” and “Hey Mister”. Both are performed by him unaccompanied – the former is played on guitar, and “Hey Mister” is played on piano. The songs have a disaffected outlook on life and politics respectively, and I think they would have made for interesting group performance.

Speaking of Paul playing solo, that is also the way most of the featured demos are presented – he plays “Burning Sky” on acoustic, “The Eton Rifles”, “Thick As Thieves”  and “Saturday Kids” on electric, and he handles both guitar and bass on “But I’m Different Now” (which lacks every ounce of punch without Rick’s drums). The demo of “Boy About Town” is a group one, but it is not really a demo – it is more of a rough mix.

For fans of Weller, this album is intoxicating. The one complaint I have is that there were enough truly unreleased alternate tracks and rarities spotlighting the whole band to fill an entire CD – the boxed set “Direction Creation Reaction” (1997) made that clear. A slew of these group performances could have been added to “Extras” in order to give it a more collective feel. As it stands, it transmits the idea that The Jam was Paul’s band. That is not entirely inaccurate, of course – he led the band, he wrote their own material and when he said “That’s it” that was it. Did this album add more fuel to the fire that resulted in the book “The Jam – Our Story” by Buckler and Foxton? Hmm…

Rating: 7/10

{ 3 trackbacks }

Greatest Hits – The Style Council | MusicKO
March 23, 2010 at 12:52 pm
Full Moon Fever (Tom Petty) – Album Review | MusicKO
May 12, 2010 at 1:18 pm
Lucía Ferreira – Uruguayan Unsigned Artist | MusicKO
June 30, 2010 at 11:59 am

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: